On its way to Earth, the universe’s oldest light may have been rotated by a fraction of a degree. That would hint at physics outside what the Standard Model can explain. The catch is that a telescope with slightly misaligned detectors would create nearly the same rotation.
A group of physicists at the University of California San Diego has developed a way to test for that sort of instrument error. They aren’t saying the question of whether the twist is real has been answered. What their method offers is a second, independent route for spotting instrument flaws before anyone claims new physics.
Postdoctoral Fellow Anto I. Lonappan led the work with Chancellor’s Distinguished Professor of Physics Brian Keating and Associate Professor of Physics Kam Arnold. The study appeared in The Astrophysical Journal Letters.
A twist that could come from the sky or from the telescope
Researchers call the signal cosmic birefringence. It is a possible rotation in the polarization of the cosmic microwave background (CMB), the faint radiation left behind from about 380,000 years after the Big Bang.
Earlier studies have hinted that the CMB’s polarization could have turned by only a fraction of a degree during almost 14 billion years in transit. The number is small, but if it survives scrutiny, the consequences for fundamental physics could be large.
The problem: polarization detectors misaligned by a comparably small angle could produce the same apparent rotation. When all the detectors share one alignment error, the data has no way of separating that error from a genuine cosmic effect.
“The signal we are looking for is incredibly small, so we have to be certain that we are seeing the universe and not our instrument,” Lonappan said. “Our method gives us a complementary way to check that distinction. Before interpreting a tiny rotation as new physics, we want to know that the calibration itself can be trusted.”
How the cross-check works
Instead of relying on the standard single combined measurement, the UC San Diego researchers compared individual polarization maps built from different groups of detectors.
A real cosmic birefringence signal should look identical in each of those maps. Setting the maps against one another cancels whatever rotation they have in common. The remainder reveals how each detector group’s calibration differs from the rest, bringing to light inconsistencies that could cloud the search for new physics.
As a test, the team worked through eight polarization maps made from observations by the European Space Agency’s Planck satellite. They checked their findings against the Minami-Komatsu analysis, an established technique for separating instrumental rotation from possible cosmic birefringence.
Each method depends on different assumptions, and the two gave consistent results. That provides an independent check on how relative calibration errors between detectors are being assessed.
What the method can’t do
The researchers deliberately built a limit into the design. Since the technique strips out any rotation shared by all the maps, it cannot on its own measure the overall polarization angle, and it cannot say how far the universe may have rotated the light.
Determining that absolute rotation still depends on a separate reference for calibrating the overall angle.
To demonstrate how the work lines up with current measurements, the team paired its reconstruction of relative calibration differences with the common calibration value from the established analysis. The result was an estimated cosmic birefringence angle of 0.37 ± 0.12 degrees, the same as the Minami-Komatsu result.
This agreement is not independent confirmation that the ancient light has rotated. It shows that the new method can reproduce the existing framework’s result while handing scientists a separate tool for probing calibration problems.
The same error could fake a gravitational wave discovery
The approach could prove even more useful in a different cosmology search: looking for gravitational waves from the universe’s first moments.
CMB polarization is divided into two patterns. E modes, first detected in 2002, arise from density variations in the early universe and form symmetric patterns. B modes have a different look, with patterns resembling curls or swirls.
Gravitational lensing is one known source of B modes. In lensing, the gravity of matter lying between Earth and the early universe bends the path of the ancient light. These lensing B modes have already been observed.
Scientists are also hunting for another B mode signal, one that primordial gravitational waves might have created. These ripples in spacetime may have arisen during inflation, a very early stretch of rapid cosmic expansion. Nobody has detected that signal yet. Detecting it would provide strong evidence about gravitational waves in the early universe and could lend strong support to particular models of inflation.
Calibration matters here too. A small error in a telescope’s polarization calibration can cause part of the far stronger E-mode signal to leak into the data as B modes, which means an instrument artifact could be mistaken for a cosmological discovery.
Because the UC San Diego method flags differences in polarization angle calibration between detector groups, it could help future experiments hunting for primordial gravitational waves catch that kind of mistake.
“The detection of primordial B modes would transform our understanding of the early universe, so the measurement must survive rigorous calibration checks,” Keating said. “Anto has developed a useful new framework for testing relative polarization-angle calibration. This is ultimately about knowing when we can trust a measurement.”
Keating is principal investigator of the Simons Observatory, one of the facilities developing the ability to measure cosmic polarization more precisely. As such instruments become more sensitive, researchers will need equally strict methods for confirming that a faint signal comes from the universe and not the hardware.
Why a fraction of a degree matters
The Standard Model, the leading theory of fundamental particles and how they interact, has a strong record. Even so, it cannot account for what dark matter is, or for where dark energy comes from and why it has the size observed. Between them, the two make up about 95% of the universe’s total energy density.
One suggested explanation for cosmic birefringence points to a hypothetical field linked to axion-like particles. A field like that could interact with light and gradually alter its polarization as it travels across the universe. These particles have not been confirmed to exist, and they would not necessarily be what dark matter is made of.
Other theories connect the possible rotation to fields associated with dark energy, the phenomenon tied to the universe’s accelerating expansion.
Where the light came from
At roughly 380,000 years old, the universe had cooled enough to turn transparent, letting light move freely through space. While that radiation scattered off free electrons during the transition, it gained a small amount of linear polarization.
Polarization is the direction in which light’s electric field oscillates. Something similar happens when sunlight scatters through Earth’s atmosphere.
The CMB captures the “baby universe” as it was almost 13.8 billion years ago. Should cosmic birefringence be confirmed, that snapshot could become a new tool for studying dark matter and dark energy. First, though, the twist has to pass calibration checks like this one.





















STAY ALWAYS UP TO DATE