GTA 6 Dubious Provenance guide: give Halifax the statue, then shoot or spare him

gta 6 dubious provenance guide give halifax the statue then shoot or spare him Spoiler warning: Dubious Provenance is a three-part Chapter 3 mission, and this page covers its choices and how Halifax's storyline ends.

Spoiler warning: Dubious Provenance is a three-part Chapter 3 mission, and this page covers its choices and how Halifax’s storyline ends.

Early walkthroughs report that shooting Benedict Halifax and sparing him at the end of Dubious Provenance both work out fine. The bigger decision comes first. Hand him the statue and you get a watch, and Parts 2 and 3 stay available.

We have not played the game. What follows sums up walkthroughs released on launch day. Some details can change from save to save, and we check again as players send in reports.

GTA 6 Dubious Provenance: Lucia sitting on a yellow motorcycle at night in a leather jacket, a neon liquor bar sign behind her

Mission overview

  • Mission: Dubious Provenance (Visit the Antique Store), three parts, Chapter 3.
  • Unlocks: once Dealer’s Choice is done.
  • Characters: Lucia or Jason.
  • Part 1 begins at the bag in the closet of the Bayside apartment in Vice City. Parts 2 and 3 are set in Capri, Mariana County.
GTA 6 Dubious Provenance: Jason and Lucia seen from behind, holding a duffel bag, a red case and rifles in front of a burning car

Part 1: the statue

You can’t skip this part. Get to Capri by car or with RideMe. Evelyn, the owner, won’t appraise the statue. Benedict Halifax, who works with her, offers an off-the-books appraisal and hands over his watch as collateral.

Either give Halifax the statue and take the Crowex Octane “Bobby Ambrose” watch, or say no. Turning him down still lets you call him back later.

Part 2: the antique store and the motel

Part 2 unlocks when Halifax stops responding after you hand over the statue.

  1. Head back to Evelyn Andrews Antiques.
  2. Get inside through the back window, or force the door.
  3. Look in the desk drawer for the statue.
  4. Search the motel next door, then choose whether to trust Halifax. You need to trust him to reach Part 3.

Part 3: the chase

Evelyn phones with an address. The pursuit of Halifax runs by seashark, boat, on foot and by bike. He hits Jason with pepper spray. Playing as Lucia, you use focus to shoot him in the leg, phone Jason, and then decide whether to shoot or spare him. Walkthroughs report that either option is fine.

Rewards and consequences

  • The Crowex Octane watch: put it on at a wardrobe via Accessories, then Watches.
  • Roughly $2,500 in cash and jewellery from the storage container.
  • A ’32 Hustler, yours to keep or sell.

There are no reported bugs.

Tips and pitfalls

  • To play the full mission, act on the optional prompt to call Halifax. It vanishes when Chapter 3 ends.
  • Trust Halifax at the motel, because Part 3 relies on it.
  • Skipping Parts 2 and 3 won’t stop the story. You just lose the extra money.
  • The watch isn’t equipped for you, so put it on at a wardrobe afterwards.

The Chapter 3 setting

Dubious Provenance covers two counties of the map. Part 1 starts in Vice City at the Bayside apartment, and the later parts shift to Capri in Mariana County, so expect a drive or a RideMe trip between them. Parts 2 and 3 depend on a prompt that runs out at the end of the chapter. Make the optional call before pushing on with the next main story missions.

About this guide

GTA 6 launches on 19 November 2026 for PS5 and Xbox Series X|S. No PC date has been announced. All mission details on this page come from walkthroughs posted at launch, and with the game only days old, some may be corrected. Values that look random and minor choices can differ between saves. If your copy shows something else, go with what’s on your screen.

FAQ

Should you give Halifax the statue in Dubious Provenance?

Yes, if you want the Crowex Octane watch and the later parts of the mission. Handing over the statue in Part 1 gets you the watch. You can also refuse and call him back later.

Should you shoot or spare Halifax at the end?

Either one works. According to the walkthroughs, both choices are fine.

Can you miss the rest of Dubious Provenance?

Yes. Ignore the optional prompt to call Halifax and it disappears when Chapter 3 ends, taking Parts 2 and 3 with it. The story carries on, but you lose the extra money.