Some players who paid Nintendo $10 for the Switch 2 upgrade of Pikmin 4 say what they got was longer loading screens.
Pikmin 4: Nintendo Switch 2 Edition + Dandori Academy launched last Thursday. The upgrade to the 2023 Switch game adds new levels and sharper, higher-resolution graphics. User reviews are stacking up online, and many buyers say they ended up with a worse version of a game they already had.
“This is essentially a paid downgrade and calling this a ‘lazy Switch 2 Edition’ or a ‘waste of money’ is an understatement for what is supposed to be an upgrade,” wrote PrestonandTom in a user review.
The figures in the complaints
Reviewers are getting into the details. According to PrestonandTom, standard load times rose from “six seconds to 30+ seconds,” and the frame rate slipped from a “consistent 30 FPS to an inconsistent 30 FPS.” A number of other players described the same combination of slower loading and dropped frames.
Kevosan was blunter. “Actively makes the game worse,” the review reads. “Longer load times than on NS1, frame drops, and glitches. The new content is NOT worth the trade-off. Standards are in the depths with this one.”
The new content in question is Dandori Academy, the set of extra levels that accounts for half of this edition’s reason to exist. Some players describe those levels as repetitive and say they reuse areas from the main campaign. Many reviewers see it as a mode built from old maps, running on hardware that they say handles the game worse.
The parts critics do like
Even the harshest reviewers agree on a couple of points. The Switch 2 version runs at a higher resolution, and no one appears to argue otherwise.
Voice support has its fans as well. Players can now shout commands at Oatchi, the strange dog-alien that tags along with your crew, and some users called that a welcome addition. It’s a small improvement, but players did point to it.
The Pikmin subreddit is calmer
Reaction on the Pikmin subreddit is more measured. Some fans there called the negative reviews overdramatic, and one Redditor objected to how low some of the review-bombing scores dropped. “0.6 is a score I’d only give to a game that is sub-functional,” the Redditor wrote.
Other posters stood up for Dandori Academy itself. They accepted that the maps are reused but said new enemy placements and other tweaks make those areas play differently. Players who like rerunning the same cave to shave down their time may find that argument fair.
How it compares with other Switch 2 upgrades
Nintendo’s Switch 2 upgrades of original Switch games have been a mixed bag so far. Kirby and the Forgotten Land received a decent amount of new content along with noticeable performance improvements. Xenoblade Chronicles X got a cooler reception, and many Pikmin fans are now putting Pikmin 4 alongside it.
Fans on both sides of the review dispute have a larger concern in common. Pikmin 4’s changes look thin next to the other Switch 2 editions, and plenty of longtime fans take that as a sign that Nintendo gives the series less priority than its other big releases.
Nintendo has not announced Pikmin 5. It has announced a series of Pikmin shorts, which means the franchise’s next outing will be a cartoon.
























STAY ALWAYS UP TO DATE